5 Craigslist Scams to Watch Out For in 2025: Apartment & Car Scams

Published on February 07, 2025 by SureBuy.io Team

Craigslist continues to be a go-to for local buying and selling in 2025, but it also remains a prime target for scammers. Whether you're looking to rent an apartment, buy a used car, or score a deal on electronics, you need to be aware of the risks. Below are the five most common Craigslist scams we’re seeing this year—and how SureBuy.io can help you avoid them.

1. Apartment Rental Deposit Scams on Craigslist

Scammers often steal photos and descriptions from real listings, then repost them with their own contact info. They ask for deposits or application fees before letting you view the property — and disappear once they get your money.

• Avoid listings with unusually low rent for the area
• Watch for urgency tactics like "act now or lose the deal"
• Never wire money or send payments before touring

SureBuy.io can flag scammy language and red flags in rental descriptions before you engage.

2. Used Car Scams to Be Aware Of

Fraudsters may advertise vehicles they don’t own, often with “too good to be true” pricing. Some even manipulate VINs or claim they’re overseas and need to ship the car.

• Beware of sellers pushing for a quick sale or shipping arrangements
• Always verify the VIN and ask for maintenance records
• Meet at the DMV or a public space to confirm title and registration

3. "Too Good To Be True" Pricing Red Flags

Unusually low prices are often bait to draw attention — especially for electronics, designer goods, and vehicles. These listings are designed to get you emotionally invested before a scam unfolds.

• Compare prices across platforms like eBay, Facebook Marketplace, or OfferUp
• Use reverse image search to check for stolen photos
• If the price feels off, it probably is — use SureBuy.io to verify

4. How to Verify Legitimate Craigslist Listings

Legit sellers typically provide:

• Multiple specific photos (not stock or blurry images)
• Detailed descriptions with brand names, models, or specs
• Willingness to meet in person, answer questions, and show receipts

Copy/paste any suspicious listing text into SureBuy.io. Our AI can detect patterns used in common scam attempts across categories.

5. Safe Meetup Tips for Craigslist Transactions

Even if the listing checks out, the meetup is where many scams (or safety issues) occur:

• Always meet in a public, well-lit place — police departments often offer “safe zones”
• Bring a friend and tell someone where you’re going
• Don’t carry large amounts of cash; use verified platforms like PayPal Goods & Services

Most scams fall apart when buyers insist on face-to-face meetings. Use SureBuy.io for added peace of mind before you get to that step.

Ready to protect yourself on your next Craigslist deal? Try SureBuy.io now.